1 -- Honest.
2 -- Can kill.
3 -- Female.
I just take all the women that are in the game.
Pink Knight. It's all true, doesn't fit.
Chaplain. Fits, but I don't believe that a peaceful player would lie specifically on question 2. The same goes for Creat and the other peaceful women without weapons.
Kitsune. Could have answered like that if she chose the NOT HONEST status for this night, but she should have understood, if she has any brains, that no one would believe that a peaceful player answered.
Hydra. The same. There are peaceful options for the questions, but that would be self-incrimination.
If there's a lie on question 3, then there's only one option - Samurai.
I conclude that Alexandrite is definitely an evil role...
Can anyone give me an example of a peaceful role that could answer these questions in this way, but in a way that looks reasonable...
Added 2 minutes later
Oh no, I missed Raphael.