what's the current, most up-to-date version of what happened last night, Ursula? I'm getting confused with the role descriptions and it's hard to figure out what happened. I'll go by her version later.
Regarding the "free execution because there's a resurrection" - it's actually debatable, even though I understand why many people think that way. The town roles are all very strong, but there are clear leaders in the form of the Smith and the Prince, possibly the Wanderer.
So, I think losing a resurrection on a random draw and not being able to revive a very important role is bad. The Chaplain can, of course, be killed, but the chance is still small enough that you shouldn't just throw away ultimates like that.
Added after 39 seconds
and yes, as soon as I have time, I'll go and figure out what you guys wrote.