Mafia 76. Illumination

Or maybe we should vote for number sixteen? I swear, that's where the Mafia is. If number sixteen isn't Mafia, then I... I... Well, I'll give you all the tea for free.

Boo-hoo-hoo, voting for number sixteen! That's obviously a bad deal! Because if I'm not Mafia, why would you want toothless Kosha and bad tea? ;)
And if I am Mafia... then I'm cute! Really! Tox will confirm!! :D

Added 6 minutes later

Mortulus could also be one of the Fingers.

Why? Please explain... .______.