TOURNEY "Sea Battle" - rules and discussion

So, how do we play?
If I were in the judges' place, I would tell the dissatisfied ones to go away, as it should be done. Democracy is democracy, but things won't move forward this way.

Since everything is already decided, I created a small statistical table (if the judges don't mind). I ask the participants to take a look and criticize it in ICQ.
http://sderni.ru/202824 - file for Office 2007
http://sderni.ru/202825 - file for Office 1997-2003