No resurrection -> no guardian.
In general, this is incorrect.
The peaceful players Dag and MyHighness didn't vote for Oot's execution -> 3 peaceful players.
Dag is understandable, but who do you consider MyHighness to be? I highly doubt they are a "Guardian," because the paladin wasn't attacking them; they simply "took the threat upon themselves." The Guardian doesn't have non-damage protection, but the Engineer does. And the Engineer can also shoot, so the conclusion is obvious...
So, there are options.