Let's talk about our Red Rush strategy...

This is an even more correct approach. But it's also more complex. If you have the time and desire, give it a try. So far, all I've heard from you are general, abstract arguments about how things might be. I'm not arguing that a rush strategy might work in certain situations. The question is how often these situations occur and how well the blue side can counter them. My opinion is that these situations are rare and usually happen because of a mistake by the blue side. And that's what I'm trying to explain.