After carefully analyzing the ratings, I came to the conclusion that the second option is still more objective (the option that takes into account the results of the 3 best players). I will list the obvious advantages of this option:
1. Relatively weak players will not be afraid to participate in the tournament, as they may lower the clan's rating. (i.e., this option will not affect clan activity in any way)
2. Weak players will have an incentive to learn in order to be among the "best" three.
3. Clans that do not have 3 representatives in a particular version will have an incentive to invite strong players, or (preferably) to develop their own champions (which, in my opinion, is the most important task for all clans).
I wrote about these positive aspects a little earlier. But there is one negative aspect. If desired, it is possible to create a fake player for the clan.
Added 3 minutes ago
Well, I don't know. The option of counting only if there are three participants, in my opinion, is not very good. There will be too few people to count then. Developing champions is good, but not everyone will want to play in any of the versions. And inviting people to bring in ratings is somehow mercenary. Clans are also for communicating with like-minded people. IMHO.
Added 20 minutes ago
When you played in the tournaments for which the calculation was made, you were not a member of a clan.
If you pass the first stage of the ВК tournament, your result (for this tournament) will be counted towards the clan's score.
---------------
List of registered clans on HeroesWorld:
Name Leader Date of creation Date of registration
"Dark Templars" - "Dark Templars" Supreme 16.09.06 17.09.06
"Soulkeepers" - "Soulkeepers" ***JOKER*** 21.09.06 23.09.06
"E pluribus unum" – "From many, one" CTPAHHuK 17.09.06 27.09.06
"Haven" - "Alliance of light" Inquisitor 23.08.06 24.10.06
Clan "Order of the Phoenix" - "Order of the Phoenix" Qwerty 07.11.06 07.11.06
Clan "Announcers of fate" - "Announcers of fate" Джомалунга 07.11.06 14.11.06
Clan "League of Tournament Soldiers" - "League of Tournament Soldiers" Prorock 15.11.06 19.11.06
Clan "Homo homini" - "Homo homini" AlexeyPank 05.01.07 15.01.07
-------------------------------------------------
Look at the date of clan registration! The tournament for the fifth version ended on 10.08.2006. There were no clans at all at that time. Nevertheless, the players' rating is counted in the clan result, and me and the Haven clan are being ignored. Dear Kyle, can you provide a report on who and when joined the clan and compare this with the dates of the corresponding tournaments?! The work you did is unlikely to have been carried out, but you figured out how to brush me off :)
Since the rating is calculated preliminarily, and by the time of the second recalculation, I managed to join the clan, I believe that my rating should also be included. You should make a SEPARATE announcement about when old players will no longer be taken into account for the rating recalculation. Then there will be no questions. But I did join. And I ask you to recalculate the rating for the Haven clan.