Skip to content

Preliminary clan ranking on HW.

User Avatar
#11
Auto-translated
Option #1.
IronAxe;65498
Who knows what anyone might say. I joined a Clan and said that I play any version of Heroes, but immediately added that I won't have time for everything – I'll be watching and choosing which Tournament to play. So, if I only have time to play in one Tournament, will I bring zero points to the Clan in all the others? Please answer – have I understood this point correctly? If so, I won't vote for the first option. I think the reason is clear.
By the way, I agree.

Option #2.
IronAxe;65498

...but it somehow doesn't seem right if there are more participants from the Clan in the Tournament than the specified number of participants to be counted...
Why "doesn't seem right"? Count the top three, for example. If only two are playing, then both count, but only two, not three – this is already a problem for the team, i.e., a "penalty" for the absence of the third, but there is an incentive to invite strong players to the Clan. If more than three are playing, then there is a choice – this is a bonus for the team for the activity of its participants.
IronAxe;65498

All participants in the Tournament should be counted, but for each Clan, the arithmetic mean should be found.
This creates the conditions for kicking weak players out of the Clans. Or refusing to accept them because of their low skill level. Or, as an option, a preliminary check of the participants' save files for results in order not to put weak players forward and spoil the Clan's rating. But this will not allow weak players to gain their own rating. There is a contradiction. And if someone thinks that this is not important, then I assure you – it is not important until the rating means something to you... :) As soon as there is an interest in the rating, thoughts about its optimization immediately arise... Only not all optimization methods are good for all members of the Clan. :)

Option #3.
IronAxe;65498
Of course, don't include them :) Will the Clan players play and start, and then also pay for someone who couldn't play in this Tournament?
And again, I agree! :)
Сначала было слово...
FizMiG v.2.0 *** Очередное обновление справочника! *** http://vk.com/fizmig