Skip to content

Round table

#3291
Auto-translated
PReDS
If you are in a stalemate situation in battle, what should the attacking player do?
The rules provide an example of the most common situation leading to a stalemate, but this does not mean that it fully covers the list of situations in which this rule should be applied. Sometimes, examples are given in the form of a battle between 1 troll and 1 troll, or 1 ghost against 1 ghost. That is, the problem is not in the lack of knowledge of the Season rules, but in the lack of knowledge of the laws of elementary logic: confused:

Added 7 minutes ago
Who and when made it mandatory? Please provide the rule.
Where in the rules does it say that in Heroes, players must attack each other and fight? And there are many things not written in the rules. What are battles for in general – to contemplate? And if you have already entered into a battle, then, based on
the laws of elementary logic
, you need to win/lose or run away/bribe. If there are shackles, then only win/lose. All possibilities for implementing one or another option exist for the attacking player. And if there are no detailed descriptions of "absurd" situations on the forum – when opponents do not want to fight (not stalemate situations), then you need to refer to practice, including from other resources
If the battle ends in a draw, then the ATTACKING player must surrender or run away


Added 1 hour 21 minutes ago
Medium_HP

P.S. In fact, we have a situation in which both players act in full accordance with the rules, but the battle cannot be completed. I believe that such a situation can be called a "stalemate" for the same reason as in the example with gnomes and a fly.
You are playing with concepts :) A stalemate situation is initiated by one side – the defending side (the losing side, which does not have a material advantage), which, through skillful actions, prevents itself from being destroyed, but also cannot win. So even with quotation marks, it doesn't fit.
You can do many other inappropriate things in full accordance with the rules. The situation is, of course, not described in the rules... although there is a connection with
players must ... respect each other
And the game seems to be a fun game. The judge would make a decision in accordance with the spirit of the tournament.