Player rating for tournaments across all installments of Heroes.

Not just for beginners. Any player whose current rating has dropped due to low activity will receive this bonus, regardless of their skill level. But, I agree, the bonus is still not very large. And this is a reasonable price to pay for a more balanced system. You insist on only considering the player's results. I believe it is wiser to consider all factors. And let's leave it at that. There is no argument here.

That's what I said – everyone is right in their own way. You believe that all factors should be taken into account and bonuses given for them, and I believe that some of these factors lead to an incorrect balance, distorting the real results of players. And again, I can calculate a rating for our player based on a game in a tournament on another resource. You are unlikely to be able to do this, since no rating is kept there. What do we conclude? That anyone who wants can come up with their own rating system and, if they wish, keep it and publish it in their own separate thread. The forum rules do not prohibit this. And who will look at which table is a personal matter for everyone, and which system each person will use for their own needs is also a personal matter. Here's an example. Kyle took a non-linear system, calculated the ratings for all clan players, and calculated the clan rating based on this. If he wants, who will stop him from calculating the same thing using the oscillator and also taking into account the AlexPanka coefficient? Therefore, I absolutely agree with you – there are no arguments and there cannot be. Everyone has simply promoted their own rating system in their own way