Appeals Committee. Disputed situations in tournaments.

Treatise: on the delights of being a sewage worker.

So, to the point. I must say that a certain body, which I will henceforth refer to as AK, has engaged in a rather interesting dialogue with me. Or rather, there has been no dialogue at all. When a well-known player, HW Numone, deigned to send me information via ICQ, his only question was how I managed to have 5 save files on my computer. HOW could 5 save files appear, and how could they be viewed for 5 days??? I don't quite understand. I possess the codes nwcwhatisthematrix and nwcnebuchadnezzar, but I still watch 5 save files of the game. How is that possible??
Here, I made a big mistake. Instead of immediately sending this biased and mediocre hero, Numone, on a long walk, after he admitted that he had not even EXAMINED the save files.
I, for some reason, started describing the game situation and the course of the battle to him. Which, apparently, was of no interest to player Numone. I admit, I haven't fully recovered from the unexpected flu that hit me.
And I didn't properly assess the situation.

Regarding his mediocrity, I can't disagree, but as for his bias, you're wrong. I don't mix flies with cutlets, and I'm not entirely sure that putting you on the blacklist was a positive decision from the point of view of re-education. In my opinion, more gentle methods would have been effective, but I'm not the whole AK; there are other people there with their own experience and perspective.

So, what am I waiting for? If, as AK suggests, I gained an advantage during the game with Alexander.
namely
then it was quite expected to hear what kind of advantage it was and how it was realized. If AK interprets the situation in such a way that I, say, hacked the map, but did not use the information obtained in any way, then I ask that this be stated in clear and concise text.

Well, well, now you're expecting something from AK, after sitting around instead of defending yourself when there was still time and reason to do so.:smile20:
You discredited yourself primarily through your behavior, and what was the point of me looking at the save files you sent two days later, after you had spent time contemplating how to get out of the situation? I asked you a simple question in ICQ, asking for a detailed description of what happened from your perspective, and that's all. And I got what I expected, namely that you consider "small amounts of offline play" in your games to be quite acceptable. Especially in such difficult moments as turn 126 in the game with Twaryna. If Javdet were in your place, I could have calmly accepted his position of "just looked and thought," even though this action is prohibited (the rules clearly state this, and everyone understands the meaning of this wording; there's no need to distort things), but you are an apple from a different tree, with completely different standards of what is permissible and concepts of honor.

The rest is just pointless arguing.