Mafia: general discussions.

Ortonna messed up in about ten games, did that really fix anything?

I'm amazed by the "rat mafia" that, upon being revealed, immediately started whining about CANCELLING THE EXECUTION and MASS MURDERS.
I'm for traditional rules. You're revealed - you're out, and the day continues as before.

They didn't want to listen, analyze, guess the hints, or simply use their brains - that's their problem. And the mafia has nothing to do with it.

I think the whole team shouldn't suffer because of some unique individuals. I understand that they have some problems, including a lack of self-control, but that doesn't mean everyone else should suffer. Why should the whole town suffer because of Ortonna? Why was the day closed early because of his lack of restraint?

Well, damn it, I think that helping the mafia in a situation that's already advantageous for them is no better than revealing someone, which gives an advantage to the town.

They could have done what they usually do: a day with an execution and a murder, and the game would still be interesting, and everyone would be happy.

I still want to remind everyone that the ratio would still be 4-2-1, and that's a playable scenario.