You are a moderator, so you should be the one to make a decision. But in my opinion, turning a blind eye to such player behavior is not acceptable. There was a precedent with Влк — based on it, moderators act primarily based on personal sympathy or dislike toward a person. That is not right.
I didn't know this. The very content of the clause and the number of points for it suggest tyranny. It's understandable that everyone is too lazy to complain to someone higher up about every little thing moderators do. So it turns out we have to put up with any abuse from moderators that might pop into their heads. There is no freedom of speech. You can give me violation points for this post, but understand and forgive HellLighT, since he is the tournament organizer...
That's exactly the point — moderators are guided primarily by their own subjective view of the situation, rather than immediately assigning points by the book. Thankfully, we have a democratic forum that allows for a more or less informal interaction. Nobody has canceled points for direct insults, and they will be assigned if there are repeat offenses.
As for the subject at hand, you could have resolved this problem like a man — talk to HellLight on ICQ and settle who is right. But, according to him, you start swearing at him in private messages, while on the forum you try to act all high and mighty. I don't understand this.