Pit for LM
Auto-translated
I am very sorry that you think so. Confidence and evidence are different things. This is what the elected (not appointed) President of the Russian Federation said. Unfortunately, at some point, the AK stopped understanding this. There is nothing to say about combining investigation and court in one structure.
Of course, you can draw parallels.
Are you suggesting that we elect a President in HOMM3? Or maybe you should first practice in Heroes 2? And then, based on the experience gained, teach us why and how.
In any case, this issue is not within the competence of the AK. So we will not deal with it.
In real life, different countries have different requirements for a presidential candidate, including:
- age limit (= gaming qualifications in our forum),
- legal capacity (= adequacy),
- residency requirement (= registration date on the forum?),
- not being in prison (= not being on the Blacklist?),
and so on....
We can also recall that in Denmark, for example, until the reign of the current queen, women did not have the right to inherit the throne. That is, theoretically, a gender requirement is also possible for the President; I don't know if it exists in the laws of any modern country.
In various jurisdictions, the powers of judges and the requirements for them differ. Judges usually have special training, in addition to a higher legal education. In some countries, a jury trial is required for a number of criminal cases, but civil cases are considered only by judges. Sometimes judges have the powers of investigators; in any case, they are not obliged to be limited only to the evidence presented during the hearing.
Usually, judges are appointed by the executive or legislative authorities; in a number of US states, Swiss cantons, and some other countries, judges are elected by the population.
There are guarantees of the inviolability and non-removability of judges. In many countries, judges are appointed for life (usually, until a certain age limit) in order to eliminate political or psychological pressure on them from the executive branch or voters.
Even in reality, people in different countries come up with different laws, so in our small "state" (population - several hundred), which is based on one single virtual aspect - the game HOMM3, we have the right to introduce some of our own specific rules that would regulate the relationship between players and try to find a structure that would monitor compliance with these rules. And it is not at all necessary to tie these rules to the laws of a particular real country, draw parallels, and oblige the forum to act according to a certain pattern.
Therefore, everything is open for discussion. If someone on our forum needs a President, let them think about why he is needed and how to elect/appoint him.