I read it, and even watched it. I came to the conclusion that it's all "ravings of a madman." It seems like Vigo is simply being targeted for removal from the forum, using every possible and impossible method. That's why they brought up all the old suspicions, mistakes, and even psychology...
I don't believe it. And here's why: 3 or 4 people, including myself, wrote that proving maphacking is very difficult, that you first need to study the person, study their style, study a lot of save files, and based on your experience, make a subjective decision, and if all members of the AC agree on this decision, then it's 99.9% maphacking. (more precisely, even an analysis of the DPK doesn't guarantee it). Studying a person and their style is partly about creating a psychological profile.
[offtopic]