I won't argue about the value – it's all very individual. Give me an example of when someone received such an award and, at the same time, had the skills suitable for a beginner? I don't see any such examples; these awards are given to seasoned veterans of the game. So, your argument is quite weak.
There are plenty of such cases. Shamys, for example, plays with a similar... several people are explaining the same thing to you, but you still stubbornly stand your ground... just be quiet and save what little dignity you have left.