It is obvious that in HL maps, BT is stronger, better, and more skillfully tuned. Everything else is just talk for the poor.
I won't write on behalf of everyone like the previous guru, but IMHO—what specifically repels me from SoD:
The impossibility of rebuilding the GM on large maps.
No chess timer.
No quick combat.
Domination of Earth Magic. If you have it—you're golden; if not, there can be big problems.
Necromancer (IMHO—stupid grinding of neutrals is for anti-heroes)
Cheat artifact—the red orb (which kills the intrigue in 70% of final battles).
Cheat artifacts: cloak and medal.
Cheat artifact boots—giving 600 mp.
Logistics units walking across half the map with a full set of artifacts at levels 20+.
I will intentionally not write about the pluses of BT created specifically for this version (such as mirror templates).
Все в ней нулево и кукольно.