Mafia: general discussions.

One way to deceive a town is to pretend to be someone else, which is what Tox did, albeit rather clumsily.

Not entirely correct. This works in psychomafia, but in street mafia, you can't clumsily pretend to be someone else.

If there's a hint and no modkill is received, even a fool will realize that the player pretending to be that role is not actually that role.

I don't know where this came from, but it should be punished in both directions, regardless of whether it's a false reveal or a real reveal.