You find it funny, but does Phoenix actually do anything? Everyone can criticize. But if you execute Phoenix now, who will manage the town?
I don't want to execute anyone on the first day, and I don't see any strong arguments against Phoenix.(Look, he's wriggling out of it; he's definitely manipulating things, I'm 100% sure, and I don't consider that a valid argument) so I'm going to execute Humer...
If you executed Humer only because you didn't want to execute Phoenix?
Added 7 minutes later
Of course, formally, this doesn't change anything, but the vote should reflect the reason for that vote.