Here, Vic is talking about the method of analysis. He says that facts (i.e., the evidence base) should be analyzed not based on emotions (an ethical method), which is what Oelm accused him of lacking, but using a logical method.
And as someone directly involved in practical jurisprudence, I can confidently state that a professional court will side with the person who presents their case clearly and concisely, like a mathematical theorem, rather than with emotional "water carriers," whom we often see in foreign films, typically with the intention of influencing the audience and a jury.
Everyone has their own style, and that's why we have a forum where everyone's opinion is needed and valued. :)
It's a shame that the discussion has turned into an off-topic debate. :(
This is some nonsense. I don't need this kind of attitude. If someone's grandfather had a WWII medal stolen, that's a matter for the police. If we're discussing a game like Heroes, it's a deeply personal discussion involving an analysis of the player's positions over several years of playing – related to the PLAYER'S PERSONALITY and having NOTHING to do with JURISPRUDENCE. Just like in a game of Mafia, the variance is worse than in poker (I've seen it in practice). NEO, you should have defended the one-portal player, but you acted like a bullet from the mud – wherever you were formed, that's where you came from.
You've gone too far bringing your work (hobby, practice, or whatever you're doing with your mistress) to the forum and showing off here. What's wrong with you? Have you completely lost sight of the connection between the quality of the game and the player's personality? Surely, you're all reasonable people!
Do you know Rebel's personality? How could there be any cheating?
A constructive suggestion: REHABILITATE REBEL, continue the tournament from the same positions! If necessary, organize an online vote AMONG ONLY the tournament participants to decide whether to continue the game from the moment of disqualification and restore Rebellious as a legitimate player