Discussion and activity are always a good thing.
If there are no controversial situations, then it's not interesting.
There are so few players left in Heroes of Might and Magic III... why are you all so eager to "criticize" each other?
There won't be any other players in this "world."
Regarding cheating or not cheating, so many programs are used offline that, based on knowledge of their names, players could be immediately disqualified from online tournaments.
My point is that the rules need to be more flexible. Players shouldn't be removed for actions that someone considers illogical.