Vic, check the saves.
I am generally surprised that Rebel is behaving this way. In Mafia, the method of hanging "for bad play" is widespread, and peaceful players often fall under it too, but if you let this slide, then every Maf will use this loophole later.
Same here — if a player doesn't care about his reputation, if in response to suspicions he curses at opponents and withdraws from tournaments, then why keep such a player in them?
Mafia is an excellent game. I think you win it often. But these things are hardly comparable. You don't see the player opposite you, you don't look them in the eye, you don't read gestures, you don't hear intonation.
Intuition is generally a powerful thing; it allows you to see a great deal from barely noticeable details. For example, I have a personal list of players about whom I decided long ago that they are shady, but due to a lack of evidence, I didn't stir up trouble. Yet, for some reason, every time someone was caught cheating, it turned out I already had them on that list. Rebel is on it. BlackKnight and Tinker too.
The accuser is a total lol.. Black Knight! Another "veteran" with an unshakable reputation.
A frankly whiny referee decision. I didn't find who made this decision, probably Sticky. If so, then forgive me, but as an organizer you are wonderful, but as a judge you are just a nightmare. Redwhite is also getting involved there. Guys, your referee authority is zero, you are young and green pipsqueaks.