Mafia 46. Lord of the Rings.

But everyone, to the very end, didn't think he was Gollum!

I would tell you what I think about everyone. But I'll pretend to be shy.
Damn, the task was solvable, seriously, it was just that those who played didn't want to think about it. That's why they lost. Conclusion (IMHO): the note trick was a giveaway, not a winning move. The city, in turn, was just messing around. As usual.

When Arandor told Tox this, he said he would say that it was all me.

Good move, but, in my opinion, it would have been very similar to flailing around. You (yes, it's the same everyone) react strangely to this kind of excuses - on the contrary, you drive it to the point of execution. I noticed this when you were "hanging" me during my time as a doctor.