Batman: Arkham city

You don't know her well.

Eagles? So, if she's a town member and says, "I don't care, kill me, but first, let's lynch Fluder," that's normal, but if she's Mafia, then no, we don't know her well! Is that right? That's a silly excuse.

Maybe it's not convincing, but I haven't found any other reasons to lynch her yet...

Oh, so besides mistakes and heresy, there's nothing else on your list... You're lacking analysis, completely.