R55Max
Auto-translated
What a load of nonsense. How much longer will you keep poking fun at whether or not such a victory is needed? If someone writes that it's needed, then it's their right.
I recently had a case where I found my mistake in a won game 3-4 days later, even though the report was already confirmed, and the mistake didn't play any role at all; it was a 100% victory. So, I had to replay, and then I lost in the next round, and my opponent advanced.
Regarding the review of saves, Dirty is right about it for now, but I think this point isn't quite well-developed. There are situations where the mistake happens at night, there are no judges available, and nerves are at their limit, including because of all these arguments. You don't want to postpone it, or you don't have time to play later, and it's unclear when it will be possible. We need to somehow select a group of about 10-15 qualified players who can always come to the rescue in reviewing saves and have the right to review the disputed situation at that moment, so that everyone can continue playing right away. And then, the tournament judge, if they suspect any violations or discrepancies, will interpret and investigate. This would significantly save time.
I recently had a case where I found my mistake in a won game 3-4 days later, even though the report was already confirmed, and the mistake didn't play any role at all; it was a 100% victory. So, I had to replay, and then I lost in the next round, and my opponent advanced.
Regarding the review of saves, Dirty is right about it for now, but I think this point isn't quite well-developed. There are situations where the mistake happens at night, there are no judges available, and nerves are at their limit, including because of all these arguments. You don't want to postpone it, or you don't have time to play later, and it's unclear when it will be possible. We need to somehow select a group of about 10-15 qualified players who can always come to the rescue in reviewing saves and have the right to review the disputed situation at that moment, so that everyone can continue playing right away. And then, the tournament judge, if they suspect any violations or discrepancies, will interpret and investigate. This would significantly save time.
МУДРЫЙ - не обязательно старый, ОПЫТНЫЙ - не обязательно мудрый... обладатель и того и другого всегда должен помнить слова НАПОЛЕОНА БОНАПАРТА: Война состоит из непредусмотренных событий; В каждом большом деле всегда приходится какую-то часть оставить на долю :smile33: СЛУЧАЯ...