- City alignments based on AD&D.

Gollum has a complex character... There's a glimmer of good in him that almost manages to win out :) (the episode where the hobbits are sleeping, and he returns from "reconnaissance"); if Sam hadn't insulted him, he might have become a good character...
And Frodo, by the way, became somewhat bad for a while.
I would say that the problem with D&D alignments is their excessive static nature. But in life, things aren't like that... For example, I was a fan of evil forces until I was 16 and considered egoism the only correct norm of behavior, but now I definitely define myself as good and altruistic:...