Skip to content

Mafia 40. In the Name of the Emperor

User Avatar
#691
Auto-translated
Let's start by sorting out the roles of the eliminated players; this is important.
ToX - Adeptus Mechanicus. He was revealed and received a modkill.
Spear - Lone Demon. The description of the execution is clear.
Zybr - Magister. The description of his death is possible for a Magister and an Inquisitor, but he is not the latter. L.Depravado - Inquisitor. Using a direct damage ability, description of the execution. With the other two (Arandor and Hostor), things are not so obvious, and this creates a problem. Instead of trying to guess their roles, we should eliminate the other possibilities. Conclusions based on their statuses and the events of the night: Let's start with Arandor. Not a Magister, not a Storm Squad Commander, not a Tactical Squad Commander, not a Devastator Commander, not the Chief Apothecary, not a Chaplain, not a Scout, not a Lord General, not an Adeptus Mechanicus, not a Commissar. From the Mafia, he could only be the Chief Librarian (according to the role description, the Ordo Hereticus Mafia doesn't fit at all, he can't be an Iterator for the same reason, and he can't be a Tech-Priest because he's still alive; the 5th Company Captain carries out his murder after the Chaplain, so Arandor can't be him either). Based on all this, Arandor can be either the 1st Company Captain or the Librarian. But I think everyone understands that he is more likely the former than the latter. Moreover, I am sure that if that were not the case, the real Captain would have reported it. Therefore: Arandor - 1st Company Captain. Now, Hostor. He cannot be: a Magister, a 1st Company Captain, a Storm Squad Commander, an Apothecary, a Chaplain, a Scout, an Adeptus Mechanicus, a Commissar. That is, his status is loyal to the Emperor, so from the first Mafia, he can only be an Iterator, and from the second, he can be no one at all (first, because they killed him, which is clear; it is also impossible to refer to the fact that the killer could have been redirected - he took an active part in the leak of the Inquisitor). His possible roles: Tactical Squad Commander, Devastator Commander, Lord General, Iterator. In addition, it is obvious that his weapon is physical. If he was an Iterator, the Heretics would have no need to write that he has an energy weapon (this creates unnecessary suspicion; almost all townspeople have physical weapons), and it would be pointless for the Ordo Hereticus to expose someone they are going to kill. Of course, one could think that the Battle Sister was redirected, but... I think that the murder of Hostor, after he took such an active part in the leak of the Inquisitor, is quite natural, in any case, more so than if a townsperson redirecting the killer targeted someone who inspired a certain amount of trust after the almost executed Inquisitor. That is, if Hostor is not an Iterator, then the note was written by the Heretics, and this makes at least some sense. Otherwise, it could only have been written by the Ordo Hereticus, but as I already wrote, this does not make much sense and is unlikely. Therefore, the Tactical Squad Commander, Devastator Commander, Lord General remain, but I will probably stop at the fact that Hostor - Tactical Squad Commander. There may be an error here, but it seems to me that the absence of an investigation report due to the death of the role is a more real reason than the daily hitting of the target by the Interrogator/Storm Squad. In general, as I said yesterday, in my opinion, Vistrit is a Storm Squad. Yesterday he was blocked, and there was no town block. And this also explains why Tox was blocked on the very first night, haha. The only nuance regarding the Tactical Squad Commander is that his investigation report is not visible in the newspaper of the second day. It is unlikely that the Tactical Squad Commander would guard Lynx, as there would be a chance of killing a townsperson. Therefore, here is a question for Lorelei: will the investigation report of the Tactical Squad Commander be displayed if he was killed this night? According to the list of investigation reports, it should, but how else to explain its absence in the second night? Unless it is because the Tactical Squad Commander has forgotten to send the investigation report for two nights in a row, but in that case, it is very sad, and all the analysis is meaningless.

Town Magister of the Order - Zybr 1st Company Captain - Arandor Tactical Squad Commander - Xostor Storm Squad Commander - not Drakkoska (block in the third night), not Lizard (was blocked, but the action still took place), not Kitz (was blocked, but the action still took place), Devastator Commander Chief Apothecary - not Rimpel (healing in the first night), not Dragnil (healing in the second night), not Vistrit (was blocked, but the action still took place), Chaplain - not Rimpel (check in the third night), not Lizard (was blocked, but the action still took place), not Kitz (was blocked, but the action still took place), not Drakkoska (was blocked, but the action still took place) Scout - not Neyra (check in the second night), not Amko (check in the third night), not Vistrit (was blocked, but the action still took place), not Lizard (was blocked, but the action still took place), not Kitz (was blocked, but the action still took place), not Drakkoska (was blocked, but the action still took place), not Dragneel, not Wishmaster, not Nebo, not Dgak, not Ple-sen Lord General Adeptus Mechanicus - ToX Commissar

Heretics Chief Librarian - not Neyra Drake 5th Company Captain - not Vistrit (there was a kill from him when he was in the block) Iterator Tech-Priest - not Vistrit (block in the second night), not Kitzunka (block in the third night), not Lizard (was blocked, but the action still took place), not Drakkoska (was blocked, but the action still took place)

ORDO HERETICUS Inquisitor - L.Depravado Interrogator - not Lizard (block in the third night), not Vistrit (was blocked, but the action still took place), not Kitz (was blocked, but the action still took place), not Drakkoska (was blocked, but the action still took place), Psyker Battle Sister - not Vistrit (there was a kill from her when he was in the block)

Lone Demon - Spear

Now let's consider the episode with Rimpel. He presents himself as a Scout and calls for Neyra to be executed. Obviously, everyone who agreed is not automatically a Scout. How was it?
Execute Neyra Drake - 8 (Dragneel, RiMpel2, WishmasteR, Nebo, Kitz Kitzunka, Dgak, Amko, Ple-sen)
That is, the Scout can only be: Rimp, Lord Mortulus, and Deliries. Unfortunately, it is impossible to say for sure here, because the latter two write little and could well have not noticed what Rimp wrote, but I still tend to think that Rimp, if he were Mafia, would not have exposed himself so meaninglessly, so he is telling the truth about Neyra's weapon, i.e., it is physical.

The next point that interested me: Lizard justified himself for my suspicion of his Mafia affiliation due to the block, saying that there are missing investigation reports from the town in the newspaper, and he did not mention the roles whose investigation reports are not displayed in the newspaper. Based on the above, only the Apothecary's investigation report is missing from the newspaper. This means that if it is not Lizard, then the Apothecary can vote for him, and then withdraw his vote (of course, this person must understand what will happen if he lies). Or, if this does not happen today, somehow hint at it in a note.
_______________________________________________________

These are just some thoughts. I may be wrong. Neyra should also be considered.
Стартовый пост - Квенты - Разное
Резара - Аксель - Орвальд - ЭмилияСтэфания - Амвросий - ЛестерАльсираАлария