Мафия 36. Fullmetal Alchemist

Yeah, he could just as easily kill townspeople.

Here, someone is saying the right thing. You can offend a townsperson.

Is it really impossible to solve Tox's clues?

The first thing a player does when accused, besides making excuses, is trying to help solve the clues. You're not helping, but you're presenting it as an argument. Not to mention that there will always be smart alecks calling any interpretation "barbarian."