What's the overall situation?
Town:
Edward Elric
Alphonse Elric
Colonel Roy Mustang
Lieutenant Riza Hawkeye
General Grumman
Major General Olivia Armstrong
Captain Maes Hughes
Shaska
Yoki
Mafia:
Fuhrer King Bradley (Wrath)
Brigadier General Basch Grand
Major Solf J. Kimblee
Lust
Envy
Solo Players:
Scar
Greed
It would be good to think about who should go where. I'm not saying to direct the town roles, but that perhaps such reasoning will help them choose the right target.
I think Deliries has a good point about Greed being the one who was killed, since the armor wasn't damaged. Although Alphonse also has 75% protection against attacks, and Olivia has 50%.
Added 1 minute ago
Oh, sorry. I missed the "not" in Kimblee's description.