I'll start by saying that the evidence against him was quite compelling.
Besides, both Kyle and Werevolka had previously voted for his execution – and they knew the Mafia player well, because they tried to recruit him on the first night, and the Mafia player was hindering them. Also, executing a town member is, to put it mildly, not the best way to clear your own name.
I don't believe that there was only a block in the third night, because I don't understand where the check on Demi is described in that case. The only thing that contradicts my version so far is the block on Xostor in the third night, but now I'm leaning towards the fact that Amko's version of that situation was correct:
Finally, Demi visited him both on the third and fourth nights, which suggests that she was most likely trying to hint that Xostor is the Mafia player by repeating the check, because Demi recognizes the Mafia player on their first visit.
Execute Zezzy. It's time to end this.
