1. Hossi and Gill are good players; it's common knowledge that good players have access to the GM panel and know all the roles by default.
2. We need to eliminate one Mafia faction so that only one remains, allowing it to breathe freely and declare victory.
3. Everything Gill says is an axiom; anyone who disagrees is a fool.
4. The concept of a "pat" is widely used in Mafia, and it can always be calculated and achieved.
The rosy-elephant-rainbow-colored outcome that you CALCULATED (actually, just assumed) is not a "pat" but a DELIBERATE loss. It's interesting how playing chess with only two pawns always leads to such an outcome, isn't it?
Except the ones we've made