Mafia 31. Twilight Dances.

And by the way, if the note about Morning is indeed a lie, then Arandor is either an angel or a mafia member. Since the golem visited him, and the abbot is dead.

That's why I don't believe Aru - he's not stupid either, he understands that since he said on the second day that he wouldn't refute the note, he should continue to pretend to be a non-mafia member. Well, when other options were ruled out, all that remained was to pretend to be the last peaceful non-mafia member, which he started to do.