Yeah, because you were giving yourself away. Notice that this time, I'm not claiming you're Mafia; on the contrary, I'm still convinced that you're just a misguided town member who thinks I'm a complete idiot. You should have read up on older games, when I was really eager to play Mafia and try to win.
Um... absolute proof /= guessing =\ I'm not saying: "SLONIK IS MAFIA, 100% SURE, LOL!!!!111" - I'm just suggesting: "this information is better than nothing."
If you want, you can sit around and wait for things to happen; if you don't, look for Mafia and use your head to figure out what's good and what's bad. Don't listen to Hosa, Gil, Arandor, etc. You need to use your own mind and draw your own conclusions, instead of relying on the leader to do everything for you. First, it's not a given that they're not Mafia (okay, I believe Gil and Arandor this time, but generally not), and second, they can also fail, because we're all human.
Giving yourself away? But in those Mafia games, you wrote that it was just your impression. :) Why didn't you point out the "obvious giveaways" and let our Mafia win twice? :)\br>And I'm suggesting that this is information for the Mafia as well, which they shouldn't be given. You're all naively thinking that you've already figured out all the roles, including Slonik's role, if he's a town member, but you're dismissing obvious options that the Mafia shouldn't be dismissing, given the number of players. Surely there should be at least one analyst there? So, this will be a useless check for the town, but useful for the Mafia, yes.
At least someone understands the meaning of what I wrote; remove your vote, don't give the Mafia another advantage.



