Mafia 31. Twilight Dances.

So, are we just going to blindly follow the crowd and execute Elephant, instead of trying to do something?

Nope, I'm not following the crowd. I'm doing this for information. If it turns out to be a mistake and Elephant is innocent, I won't die from it. I won't dwell on it or get depressed about helping the city fail. I'll just accept that I was wrong and move on, thinking about how to reduce the number of failures.
In the end, it's just a game, so there's no need to get so worked up about it. It's better to enjoy it.