Mafia 31. Twilight Dances.

I might still doubt whether Gill is Mafia (if he is, then it would be beneficial for him to frame me or any other player)...

But why would I take such a risk to protect a peaceful player? The point is that I wouldn't care who gets executed, as long as it's not one of my own.

Added 5 minutes later

1) The Mafia could have easily orchestrated this to eliminate a peaceful player and gain an extra day. This is the most likely scenario.
2) No one has even tried to connect it to any evidence.
3) Eliminating a passive player, especially Neyra, who is impossible to tell whether she's Mafia or not, is another standard Mafia tactic.
4) They killed with an Archer because she's the least useful; they already mentioned this. They were afraid of eliminating the Dancer, as it's unclear who the Maniac is targeting.

1. This isn't an argument, you know. You can be Mafia and frame a peaceful Slonysh – what's the difference? Most likely? :) You'll be surprised. 2. Hmm... How? If you haven't noticed, I don't think Neyra is the Archer. :/
3. Possibly, although I've only seen this happen once in my games. Not just seen it, but I've done it myself.
4. In my opinion, there was no need to be afraid of choosing such a victim. It would have been beneficial for the Maniac to target someone who would make more moves. But I know this isn't an argument. Reinhardt was close to being invisible after the first night.