Mafia 31. Twilight Dances.

He first directed the city's suspicions towards me, and then retracted them. Personal sympathies? Seriously, the sympathy level first dropped and then jumped back up within an hour?

It's a standard mafia tactic; you've played this game before, and so have I. This "argument" doesn't hold water. I can already foresee how Hostor will soon change his vote, justifying it with some "rational reasoning," which is perfectly clear to you, seasoned players with thousands of games under your belts.

And most importantly, everything there is absolutely logical. Where do you see any inconsistencies?

1) The mafia could have easily orchestrated this to eliminate a peaceful player and buy themselves an extra day. This is the most likely scenario.
2) No one has even tried to fit any evidence to this theory yet.
3) Eliminating a passive player, especially Nera, who is impossible to read, is another standard mafia move.
4) They killed her with an archer because she's the least useful; this has already been mentioned. They were afraid of eliminating the dancer in a risky situation, as they don't know exactly who the killer is targeting.