DISCUSSIONS on “Rules for online games in HoMM3 and formulas for calculating player rating.”

There is some inconsistency in the rules regarding the use of 4th and 5th-level magic. 5.10.4. All specialist heroes with 4th-level magic skills, as well as Tant (who has the 3rd-level spell Raise Dead), can use their respective spells against an opponent if one of the following conditions is met... but at the same time 5.11. It is forbidden to use Magic Scrolls of levels 4 and 5 without having a corresponding level Guild Hall built in any of your castles... It turns out that if specialist heroes can use magic from their spellbooks against neutrals and companions, then they cannot use the same magic from scrolls. This seems inconsistent, as it grants privileges to the AI and neutral creatures. It would be better if there was a ban on using scrolls of levels 4 and 5 against an opponent.