I didn't quite understand... was the Blacksmith's block successful or not?
Blacksmith. Special ability – Heavy Hand. Blocks a selected player. (Exception – Warlock, Templar, Grand Inquisitor, Witch Hunter)
If the block was successful: among the peaceful roles, the Thief is present. The Usurer bribed her on the first night, and the Inquisitor checked her on the second... meaning there is only one peaceful role.
If it was unsuccessful: it's either the Templar or the Witch Hunter.
The Witch Hunter kills a player with the "cursed" status. So, if the Witch Hunter comes for the soul of the player in question, even if she is a Templar, he won't kill her. But if she is the Thief, he might. However, based on the note, if it's truthful, the player in question is a Heretic, which means she can't be classified as any of the peaceful roles. Let's hope the note is genuine?
Added 5 minutes later
So, what should I say? Aren't you the one denying my conclusion? Then please, tell me where I'm wrong. :)
And why do you think it's not accurate enough?
Because I don't like the connection. Sometimes, clues immediately feel right – you feel like you've found the answer. And sometimes, there are clues that you doubt for a long time because the connection isn't very strong. But let's stop arguing about this; I admit that clues can vary in their strength. I'm just being cautious. And the main question: why did you ignore and not answer me, what role do you think Reg has?



