Mafia 29. Witch Hunt

Staying silent is the worst thing you can do in such a situation; by the way, excuses say a lot, especially those kinds of excuses. Attacking Gil is logical; it's a way to deflect suspicion.

Actually, no... they could easily have ignored this fact. If I were a Mafia member and a supporter of Gil, I would have 100% stayed silent. Knowing his "urban" reputation, it could have easily been overlooked. People tend to act out of habit.

Attacking him would be logical in 2 cases. No, even 3.
First, Gil has become very active (which isn't the case), he's already facing execution (which also isn't the case), and I (playing on the same team as him) want to clear my name by actively accusing him.
Second, I'm a Mafia member from a competing team, and I'm sure that Gil is a Mafia member, and I want to get him eliminated. Even if that were the case, Gil is still a Mafia member, and the townspeople should still pay attention to him. And yes, in this scenario, they should also pay attention to me.
And third, the most obvious reason: I really saw an interesting fact that raised suspicions...:rolleyes: