Мафия 28. The Lonely nights in Neville

Как рассчитал?)

Is this really that important? This is my personal assessment of how likely a peaceful role is, given this behavior. My confidence, expressed as a percentage, if that makes it easier for you. :) And I can assess my own confidence myself, without formulas or specific calculation methods.

Гил, мне лень искать картинку с фейспальмом.

You don't have to look; I can imagine it myself. :)

Я в каждой мафии сыплю подобными фразочками, я в каждой мафии предлагаю казнить Арандора, я в каждой мафии не отвечаю на идиотские вопросы.

And what's good about that, if you also play as Town? Is suggesting to hang Arandor, even if he's obviously Town, just your typical behavior because "that's what I always do"? And most importantly, if you can analyze things properly, decipher clues, and create plans (all of this as Town, if you've ever played that role), then why do you need all this irrational nonsense? It's not even about testing the player's reaction to an accusation; it's just "writing something to have something written." If you've always played as Mafia, then the question is moot. Then this is just your standard Mafia behavior, and there's nothing more to discuss. Not answering stupid questions – again, if you don't answer them as Town either, that's just a negative for you. Why should Town behave aggressively and hide their thoughts? It's stupid.

Для какого-либо минимального психоанализа нужно хоть немного знать человека(не так как Арандор, он смишной). Ты знаешь? Нет, тупо кинул на удачу. Мне вот интересно как можно спалиться в психомафии без улиток?
Поэтому отстой, бал вонаби-психологов. Олололо парни дави интеллектом психология решает.

Heh, psychoanalysis has never been based on knowing the specifics of a person's psychology. Psychoanalysis allows you to identify these characteristics, and then, based on what is already known, to identify further details. It's naive to think that you need to be familiar with the subject to apply psychoanalysis. I won't even comment on the possibilities of getting caught in psychological Mafia games, because you'll say it's all nonsense anyway. :D

Ох уж это нежелание признавать свои ошибки, подкосило и даже такого сильного игрока. Печально...

Liz, I'm sorry, but when I made a huge mistake at 26, I admitted it. And I listed my mistakes myself. Here, the problem isn't that I initiated your condemnation, but that you contributed to it yourself. If you were absolutely sure that player A was Mafia, everything would point to that for everyone, and player B would write that player A is 100% Town and vote for No-No-Vote, what would you think? And then, when he's accused, and when the Mafia is in such a losing position, he'll just write, "olololo, the Town are judging each other." What would you think? That he's one of the Mafia who can't fight to the end, or that he's just a Town player who doesn't care? I assumed the latter, considered it very unlikely, but I assumed it. And then what? Why did we need you alive? To later interfere with us on the last day with another pointless No-No-Vote? Useless players who contribute to their own hanging have been and will continue to be hanged.

Гопник Вася очень агрессивен, пишет агрессивные посты, агрессивно ведет себя. Но ему досталась роль врача в мафии.
Как можно голосовать не в ту сторону, если "ту сторону" определить невозможно из-за отсутствия улиток?
- Ребята, вон тот парень маф!
- Ок, ок! Маф, маф!
- Точна точна!!
- С чего он маф то?
- АГА НУ ВОТ ТЫ И ПОПАЛСЯ КАЗНИТЬ %юзернейм%!

And... So what? Just recently, in a psychological Mafia game, my Doctor was hanged because he couldn't react normally to accusations and behaved very aggressively. He was hanged, and the Mafia won (I was one of them), partly because of this. They accused this Doctor of being Mafia, and he just snapped back. How do you determine which side to vote for? It's all the same psychoanalysis. You can see who behaves how when it comes to voting. You really should play a couple of times before judging.

Не хотелось бы разочаровывать, но большее из этого может сделать и игрок за город.

Again, such useless and clueless players have been and will continue to be hanged. And that's why Town players should also try to be involved during the day. Apparently, too many people think that Town can just not think and write whatever comes to mind. They don't care about their own uselessness.

Что ж вы Гура не замочили?

It was pointless; there were better and more dangerous candidates. But yes, I suspected him of being Mafia too. I just did it more subtly, because I've heard about his quiet nature in games. In general, Masini answered many of your questions, and she answered them correctly (everything related to psychological Mafia games). Maybe she didn't answer everything, but this argument is getting boring for me, because you're not trying to accept the opposing point of view. You're sticking to your guns and not listening to anyone (or not reading). :) I won't write "don't reply to this," you'll reply anyway. I'll just say that I don't intend to reply further. :) Good luck to you. :)