Mafia: general discussions.

GamaUn, I agree that the GM can resolve any controversial situation. But they also might not. And that's why having such a rule is useful – you don't need to rely on the GM. Moreover, when a player knows there's a rule they're sure to break with their post, they won't do it to avoid getting modkilled. In the case of relying on the GM's decision, a player might decide that they won't be punished. Wouldn't it be better to ensure the quality of the game in advance? For example, I prefer a situation where Ar simply doesn't reveal the status, rather than revealing it and getting modkilled (it's not about the fact that we're on the same team – I wasn't happy about Gur getting modkilled either).