Added 4 minutes later
If we accept Hermit's version, then we have four different mafia killers for all the nights. And also, the boatswain "in action" on the first night!
Are all the mafia members crazy and behaving as absurdly as possible?
Or are we just randomly accusing anyone?
Added 2 minutes later
I vote to execute Slonysh because the suspicions still haven't cleared up.
Quietly and peacefully. No one will vote for your execution, even if a pendulum and a charred book are lying at the scene of the murder – you're not behaving suspiciously, are you?
You're not behaving at all. You're not looking for clues, you're not hanging the mafia.
Keep it up, good job.
