Мафия 25. Under The Jolly Roger!

For example, because the compass was broken, Mr. Sherlock. A broken leg cannot walk, and a broken compass cannot indicate direction.

But why even write that it wasn't pointing north? It's important that it wasn't pointing north! What does it mean to break a compass? If you fix the needle in place, what difference does it make that it wasn't pointing north???

Added 5 minutes later
I'm also starting to doubt you, because a pearl can indeed point to the Wolf...