Another thought occurred to me: the compass might not have been pointing north because there was something metallic nearby, and WishmasteR has Iron Maiden in his signature!
1 - Registrа mentioned the role of the person killed by the maniac in the first night back in the first night.
2 - Aziral'. The description of his execution contained the following phrase:
He drew his saber.
After the last phrase, the boatswain grinned maliciously.
3 - Neyra Drake (or Morning, which I think is less likely). It is clear that one of the players in this pair was a conspirator, and the other was a cannoneer, since the cannoneer's ability does not affect the boatswain, the witch, or the maniac, but it clearly worked in this case.
3DS FC - 1418-6688-8950
PS4 & VITA & PS3 PSN ID - Darkness_Zedzi