Мафия 25. Under The Jolly Roger!

Don't eliminate anyone - if the broken compass is evidence in the Mafia game, the situation becomes ambiguous. If we consider it as evidence, then theoretically Pardora could also be a suspect - her profile contains information about Treasure Island, and judging by this quote from the wiki:

Allardyce's fate was unfortunate: Captain Flint made a compass from his body, which pointed to where the treasure lay.

there was also a compass with a non-standard function, which means this evidence could be attributed to her as well. Plus, I wouldn't be surprised if it could also point to someone else - there are plenty of pirate themes in the profiles. And since I don't have any certainty yet, and I don't want to eliminate townspeople by mistake, I'll vote this way for now. I also don't see much point in targeting the serial killer, especially considering the possibility that he might switch to the town's side.