Hos, what are you getting at?
Hos, and...? What does this point to?
Seriously, this is one of the clues, and in my opinion, it's not too confusing (it doesn't point south, and the gyroscopic compass and radar don't either – are we looking for weights and military stuff? That's ridiculous), and it's not too easy (a broken compass = a broken compass... JACK SPARROW!1).
I think "sometimes a banana is just a banana." Of course, a broken compass doesn't point north.
Mafia: Morning, Slonysh, Plesen, Vishmaster...
We should also find out who might have a hook.
Manic:
...
ND: murder
Weapon: boarding hook
