Workshop

What ideas?

Regarding the plot. Okay, the roles are standard, but repeating material that has already been covered... It's not particularly great, just like with the Magog-Loldin.

Compared to the Witch Mafia, there are many changes here.

Lol.

Feature: if it tries to protect the saber-toothed tiger, it dies along with it. It has a 50% chance of surviving an attack.
Non-deterministic: player defense.

This immediately caught my eye; I won't comment on the rest.

1. No one is forcing anyone to play.

And will 22 people just show up on their own? Just get rid of it...

If there are, it's not a guarantee that they will be much better.

Something different could mean something new, not something old that has been chewed over for a long time. Besides, why ruin "remember, Revan, how we rocked the X-Men Mafia?" and change it to "wasn't the X-Men Mafia boring, don't you think, Revan?"...

P.S.:
Arandor gave himself away ^_^