Skip to content

Мафия 23. The Rockland tavern

User Avatar
#133
Auto-translated
Happy Girl
In general, the picture of the night is more or less clear.
Execute Kyle
I suggest that everyone who has a complete picture of the night express it in detail. That is, something like: "The killer is N, this is indicated by this and that. The second killer is J, because of this and that."

This will help others see the missing logical connections.

Kyle, for example, will probably be hanged anyway, but is he our primary target? After all, there are characters who, in the event of a bad player being checked, will kill him in the next night anyway, and Kyle was checked. We need to think about it better.

Added 1 minute ago
Vegtam
There will be evidence only for the one who killed. The one who was late would not have left anything at the crime scene, and would have hurried to get away. And to burn the body... unless out of spite :D

Therefore, I doubt that two people were hunting Hostor.

If two people chose the victim, then the GM could have wanted to point this out to us by mentioning a double method of killing.

Added 8 minutes ago
And tell me, supporters of the theory that the mercenary died - where is her victim? The mercenary walks in front of the killer, she would have had time to kill someone. You will tell me that she tried to kill Daerel, but was blocked by the ranger... But what was she doing at Neyra's door?! Did she take a tour of all the bedrooms?

So, if Host is the mercenary, then she was NOT going to kill Neyra, because the mercenary kills before the killer. There is no evidence of protection in Neyra's room, and the block is a key point and it would have been indicated.

Then Host could have been at Neyra's door only as a protector of the assassin. In this case, Neyra is the assassin, and Host died for him.

But there is a contradiction here. Who could have tried to kill the assassin? Only the killer. Okay, the killer killed the mercenary with an axe... but who burned her? After all, the mafia could not have chosen the mercenary as their target.:confused: