Skip to content

Mafia 21.

User Avatar
#999
Auto-translated
So, in my opinion, the peaceful players are: Lizard, Pandora, Azi, Neyra, and of course, me ;).
And probably PleSen is also peaceful.
Everyone else is suspicious.

Now I will move on to specific names.
Thorium is a murderer!
I became convinced of this after reading his post:
Thorium
Basically, good evening to everyone. Sorry for not being in the thread often, but I don't have much time.
In general, there are 6 people left in the city. In my opinion, Neyra and Azi are 95% city dwellers, as can be seen from the results of the night actions.
I also trust Pandora, Arandor, and Lizard. Mostly because of how they play. The 6th city dweller is me.
I am ready to execute everyone else. I am surprised that you don't see the obvious giveaway from Koteyko, Plesen, Moning, and Gur. They don't care who they hang! And Neyra so naively joins the general lynching. Plus, there's Registr, who quietly sabotaged yesterday and is now making a fuss about early voting.
Execute Moning. Then, according to the list...
Now I want to analyze his post element by element.

1st point
Plus, Registr, who quietly sabotaged the vote yesterday and is now making a fuss about early voting.

I sabotaged the vote because, according to my time (I have a time zone +6 hours from Moscow), the day passed in the evening and at night, and I was busy at that time and really didn't have time to log in. Also, I didn't expect the day to be shortened; it was a complete surprise to me.
Now let's move on to the fuss I raised.
Honestly, I expected you to raise this fuss (you come online earlier than me), and I would just agree ;)
Why did I expect that? I'll explain.
As far as I know, you often play psychological Mafia on FLP (or is it your doppelganger playing there? :D)
For those who don't know, I'll briefly say how the chronicle looks at the end of the night. It looks very dry. It only says who died and that's it. There is no hint of the murderer, his role, or even how the unfortunate person died (from poisoning or murder). And no other night actions are displayed. So, even though I don't have much experience playing Mafia, this is my eighth game in total (one of them was on FLP with Thorium), I have a clear idea of how they look for the Mafia in such a case. And they look for them using a comprehensive analysis: the results of the vote, the results of the night (even if they are dry results), looking for various connections (Mafia usually call each other peaceful or don't call each other at all, and try to quietly defend each other. Also, the Mafia prefer not to communicate with each other during the day), and finally, the behavior of a specific player is taken into account.
So, for this, it is extremely important that everyone votes (NNV is also a vote), or if the vote is blatantly sabotaged, it is also taken into account (for example, as Gur and Azi did yesterday, which greatly helped the angel), activity is shown, but there are no votes... Also, the discussion itself is extremely important (they even have a discussion on day zero, when there is no information at all). But here, Thorium basically said that everyone doesn't need to vote, and they don't need to discuss anything... Are you, excuse me for the question, planning to identify the Mafia using only this? Just don't say that you don't use techniques from psychological Mafia, because Mafia relies on clues.
I would still understand if someone else said that, but I don't understand why the master of psychological Mafia said that.
That's why, when I came and didn't see the "fuss" from your side, I purposefully asked you, and not someone else, to express your opinion about the day being shortened.
But if we assume that you are evil, then everything falls into place in this matter.

2nd point
Thorium, do you remember how you explained in a note why you withdrew your vote from Hermit?
"I think I withdrew my vote from Hermit for no reason. He's Mafia, specifically - a destroyer. If he weren't Mafia, the two groups would have hanged him with the city constantly making stupid decisions."
Logical. By the way...
The next day comes!
The two Mafia groups with the city constantly making stupid decisions hang Happy. Why didn't you apply the same logic here?
By the way... Didn't you write before that only a blind person wouldn't see that Happy and Neyra are city dwellers? I don't remember...

3rd point
I also trust Pandora, Arandor, and Lizard.
To confidently declare Arandor as peaceful after my analysis... For the master of psychological Mafia, this is at least strange... If you were peaceful, you would at least doubt him, so to speak, you would put him in the category of those who need to be watched... But here you confidently stated that he is peaceful.
And if we assume that he is your accomplice, then everything falls into place.

4th point
And Neyra so naively joins the general lynching.
Voting against Arandor did not look like a general lynching. He didn't even have a majority of votes (the angel helped). There is a clear distortion of facts.

5th point
I am ready to execute everyone else.
Strange... This is very strange for a peaceful player... To vote against anyone...
There is always a more suspicious or more dangerous player for the city...

Based on all these points, it turns out that Thorium is among the murderers.

And the 6th point, strangely enough, will be in defense.
Before your post, I thought Gur was the murderer.
Now I am even somewhat confused about who is the murderer of the two of you...
In general, now you definitely need to execute Moning, and I need to think more about the two of you...

Added 10 minutes ago
Most likely, Thorium is still the murderer, and not Gur.

Added 1 minute ago
Regarding the maniac. I definitely can't say anything right now... I need to analyze the clues more.
Today, he probably wanted to kill Neyra. But she was healed by the paladin.
We need to wait and see what status Koteyko will have...

Added 7 minutes ago
Pandora, I apologize again, I just can't write quickly and concisely... I should have prepared this post yesterday :)
Если эта надпись уменьшается - Ваш монитор уносят. :D