You yourself were more emotional when playing as a Mage in the previous game; now you're not. Apparently, you're either peaceful or playing as Mafia. :P
It's possible to play like that as Mafia, but when you're a Mage, the main goal is survival. It's quite difficult and more nerve-wracking; you get nervous and think about what to do. I know from experience.
Or else I'll start reminding you how much you love to make mistakes, starting with the first Mafia game and those "fish" avatars.

